insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Discussions about Cape Dory, Intrepid and Robinhood sailboats and how we use them. Got questions? Have answers? Provide them here.

Moderator: Jim Walsh

User avatar
Keyscaptainadam
Posts: 78
Joined: Aug 20th, '12, 16:33
Location: velella and flor del sol

insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by Keyscaptainadam »

My winter plans included in-water storage at a town marina.

The marina requires a 300,000 liability minimum that is costing my nearly 300 a year.

I'd rather invest that 300 in a new bilge pump, new anchor, or new storm sail, than waste it away on something I believe is preventable...i.e. disaster.

Prudence is best exercised and money best spent/invested in preventing disasters, not mitigating them in courts of law.

With hopes for some quotes under $200 for the simplest of policies...

adam
SV Velella
S/V Velella .... CD 25 moored in Cold Spring Harbor, Long Island, NY
Sailing long island waters since 2009
http://www.adam-waywell.squarespace.com/
User avatar
tjr818
Posts: 1851
Joined: Oct 13th, '07, 13:42
Location: Previously owned 1980 CD 27 Slainte, Hull #185. NO.1257949

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by tjr818 »

Have you checked with BoatUS? They have some pretty good rates,, I am not paying that much for our 27. :cry:
Tim
Nonsuch 26 Ultra,
Previously, Sláinte a CD27
User avatar
moctrams
Posts: 583
Joined: Jul 21st, '06, 15:13
Location: 1982 Cape Dory 30C,Gabbiano,Hull # 265,Flag Harbor,Long Beach, Md.

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by moctrams »

I have Progressive on Gabbiano.
User avatar
Jdpmus
Posts: 80
Joined: Jun 17th, '10, 17:45
Location: Cape Dory 25, hull #169, Zephyr III, Grapevine, TX
Contact:

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by Jdpmus »

I second the motion for Progressive. Lowest rates found and, because of an "oops", great service.
joemerchant
Posts: 181
Joined: Mar 19th, '13, 12:24

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by joemerchant »

Though I agree with you that paying for insurance just plain sucks (for lack of a better term), but being someone who had an uninsured boater do considerable damage to my boat many years ago when I just carried liability was a real pain when he couldn't or wouldn't pay for damages. They dropped the mast on our boat when trying to put it up in the slip.

I agree with you that mitigating disaster is important, but so is being responsible for your own actions. We can't mitigate all scenarios, and thus the reason for insurance.

Apologize, it is a sore subject with me.
User avatar
Sea Hunt Video
Posts: 2561
Joined: May 4th, '11, 19:03
Location: Former caretaker S/V Bali Ha'i 1982 CD 25D; Hull 69 and S/V Tadpole Typhoon Week

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by Sea Hunt Video »

Adam:

I agree with Tim. I have BoatUS and I have been very happy with them. Shortly after I purchased her in Toms River, NJ, a hurricane came right over the marina. Fortunately, the marina hauled S/V Bali Ha'i and all the other sailboats prior to the storm. There was no damage. The marina did charge me for the haul out which I expected. What I did not expect was an email from BoatUS advising all insured owners that if they hauled out to protect from the hurricane that BoatUS would reimburse a portion of the haul out fee :!: I ain't never had an ins. co. volunteer information like that. When I received the email from BoatUS I did remember that this was part of their policy coverage. I just never expected them to volunteer the information.

As for the $300,000 liability, almost all (probably all) marinas require that you have it and that they be listed as a "secondary insured payee" (or some such similar term) on the policy so that if your sailboat causes damage in the marina, the marina owners can collect from your ins. co. There is no real way around this.

As for price, because of the "agreed valuation" on S/V Bali Ha'i I pay about $450/year. In addition to the normal stuff it also covers damages from an uninsured boater which would have resolved the problem Joe Merchant mentioned in his post. While there are a lot of uninsured motorists out there, I am guessing there are a lot more uninsured boaters. Protect yourself at all times.

All said, having the Boat US insurance is a peace of mind issue for me. When I talk to them they sound like boaters who know their stuff - generally a lot more than I do. While Progressive and others (I had Allstate for one year on my earlier Ty Weekender) may have good policies and reasonable prices, when you deal with BoatUS you are, from my experience, dealing with people who spend their days dealing only with boat issues.

I also have the unlimited towing package with BoatUS. Another "peace of mind" issue with me.
Fair winds,

Roberto

a/k/a Sea Hunt "The Tadpole Sailor"
CDSOA #1097
________________________________
"I wish to have no Connection with any Ship that does not Sail fast for I intend to go in harm's way." Captain John Paul Jones, 16 November 1778, as quoted in Naval History and Heritage Command, http://www.history.navy.mil
User avatar
Gary H
Posts: 399
Joined: Oct 15th, '06, 20:19
Location: 1984 CD 22D "Light Fandango"

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by Gary H »

Another option is insuring your boat as a rider on your homeowner's policy. This is usually less expensive and if you are happy with the company that insures your home, it is a good option. That is what I do.
CDSOA Member 1389
User avatar
Jdpmus
Posts: 80
Joined: Jun 17th, '10, 17:45
Location: Cape Dory 25, hull #169, Zephyr III, Grapevine, TX
Contact:

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by Jdpmus »

My homeowners insurance (Hartford) will not allow a "secondary insured payee" on boat coverage.

YMMV
Neil Gordon
Posts: 4367
Joined: Feb 5th, '05, 17:25
Location: s/v LIQUIDITY, CD28. We sail from Marina Bay on Boston Harbor. Try us on channel 9.
Contact:

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by Neil Gordon »

Jdpmus wrote:My homeowners insurance (Hartford) will not allow a "secondary insured payee" on boat coverage.

YMMV
And my marina, while requiring liability coverage, doesn't require that they be named.
Fair winds, Neil

s/v LIQUIDITY
Cape Dory 28 #167
Boston, MA

CDSOA member #698
User avatar
tjr818
Posts: 1851
Joined: Oct 13th, '07, 13:42
Location: Previously owned 1980 CD 27 Slainte, Hull #185. NO.1257949

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by tjr818 »

Neil Gordon wrote:...And my marina, while requiring liability coverage, doesn't require that they be named.
That is the same at our marina. All they want is to be listed as an "interested party", that way they get automatic notices of our annual renewal.
Tim
Nonsuch 26 Ultra,
Previously, Sláinte a CD27
Northoceanbeach
Posts: 99
Joined: Sep 8th, '14, 00:10

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by Northoceanbeach »

Do all insurance companies require a survey? That seems like the most expensive part.
User avatar
Russell
Posts: 2473
Joined: Feb 5th, '05, 11:14
Location: s/v Lady PaulineCape Dory 36 #117

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by Russell »

Northoceanbeach wrote:Do all insurance companies require a survey? That seems like the most expensive part.
Insurerers who give policies without surveys tend to charge a premium. You can find liability policies with no survey needed and need to do the math if the extra cost is worth it compared to a survey cost. I paid $500 a year for worldwide liability at $300K with no survey, not bad really, underwritten by Markel (most brokers gave me the same quote). 2 summers ago I stayed in a marina that required $1 million liability and that cost me $1000 a year (again worldwide), I was not happy about it but I did the math on my rather inexpensive slip rent for the location and decided it was worthwhile, also underwritten by Markel. Last summer I had yet another marina, wanted $500K, I went with Progressive that time at $40 a month, no survey.

You will not find full coverage without a survey in the US, liability only can be had with Progressive and Markel (with a CD25 I suggest Progressive). Anyone else will require a survey for a 20+ year old boat. Keep in mind Markel is an underwriter, not an broker, you need to go through a broker who sells Markel (I used Global Maritime Insurance for several years).

Another option is a cut rate policy from an offshore insurer, like Nothernreef, they will insure anything for cheap, based in Gibralter and unregulated and likely wont pay a dime on a claim (they are who all the ferrocement owners get insured by, you basicly pay for the peice of paper that gets you into a marina).

Unbrella policies with your homeowners can work with a smaller boat like a 25 and you might even get full coverage that way rather then just liability, thats the first route I would explore.
Russell
s/v (yet to be named) Tayana 42CC
s/v Lady Pauline Cape Dory 36 #117 (for sale)
User avatar
Russell
Posts: 2473
Joined: Feb 5th, '05, 11:14
Location: s/v Lady PaulineCape Dory 36 #117

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by Russell »

Another note about progressive, you can do it all online, they dont get picky about particulars of this and that, you can literally get covered the same day you do it, no survey, simple, and quick. Walmart style insurance (sell a lot, sell it cheap). Real yacht insurance requires particulars and details, some of which may make your rates absurd, Progressive is simple, quick and easy (but not worldwide, its got a lot more restrictions, but I suspect you are not crossing oceans in your CD25). If you buy a policy for marina X in state Y, and you make a claim in state Z you are probably screwed, they really do more the ski boat type insurance as their bread and butter but will cover you as well with no survey.

BoatUS will require a survey, even for liability only.

If you are a USAA member, they have a partnership with both Markel and Progressive, get USAA awesome customer service while dealing with a 3rd party underwriter, win win. But I was never able to use them because they dont do insurance outside the US for boats.
Russell
s/v (yet to be named) Tayana 42CC
s/v Lady Pauline Cape Dory 36 #117 (for sale)
User avatar
Terry
Posts: 118
Joined: Jul 14th, '08, 14:31
Location: CD-25 Cassandra #567
Lake Lanier, North Georgia
www.jonahzsong.com

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by Terry »

Russel,
You mention worldwide coverage. So, is proof of insurance required to enter a foreign port, or just at a marina? Also, if the offshore insurance likely would not pay out, as you suggest, would a boat owner with such insurance still be held liable?

Regards, Terry
joemerchant
Posts: 181
Joined: Mar 19th, '13, 12:24

Re: insurance for a CD25 ... any suggestions

Post by joemerchant »

Russell wrote:
Northoceanbeach wrote:Do all insurance companies require a survey? That seems like the most expensive part.
Insurerers who give policies without surveys tend to charge a premium. You can find liability policies with no survey needed and need to do the math if the extra cost is worth it compared to a survey cost. I paid $500 a year for worldwide liability at $300K with no survey, not bad really, underwritten by Markel (most brokers gave me the same quote). 2 summers ago I stayed in a marina that required $1 million liability and that cost me $1000 a year (again worldwide), I was not happy about it but I did the math on my rather inexpensive slip rent for the location and decided it was worthwhile, also underwritten by Markel. Last summer I had yet another marina, wanted $500K, I went with Progressive that time at $40 a month, no survey.

You will not find full coverage without a survey in the US, liability only can be had with Progressive and Markel (with a CD25 I suggest Progressive). Anyone else will require a survey for a 20+ year old boat. Keep in mind Markel is an underwriter, not an broker, you need to go through a broker who sells Markel (I used Global Maritime Insurance for several years).

Another option is a cut rate policy from an offshore insurer, like Nothernreef, they will insure anything for cheap, based in Gibralter and unregulated and likely wont pay a dime on a claim (they are who all the ferrocement owners get insured by, you basicly pay fopiece peice of paper that gets you into a maUmbrellaUnbrella policies with your homeowners can work with a smaller boat like a 25 and you might even get full coverage that way rather then just liability, thats the first route I would explore.
The term "Umbrella" coverage is additional coverage normally after you are already insured to the maximum underlying policies used to extend limits. Used for people who have a lot more personal exposure such as wealth that someone would go after if sued.

You can have your homeowners insurance endorsed for a "rider" to include just about anything. It may not be satisfactory to the marina, and yes, their insurance company. Your homeowners insurance already extends liability to you for outside acts, but the rider will cover the hull. If you have expenisve equipment, etc. It is really inexpensive to add it as a rider to your homeowners. Such as a iphone...

It is best to consult with a licenced agent in your State who is fimilar with boat insurance. BOAT US, Progressive, CNA, Safeco, Travelers, Allstate, Geico, etc... Stay with a company that is A rated or better. And overseas, brokers are fine, just make sure they are underwritten by major player like LLoyds.

Also, when going with a National company like Progressive it is advisable to go through a local agent as opposed to direct. This creates a personal relationship, added level of protection, and they will actually go to bat for you in the claims process.
Post Reply