Tiller VS. Wheel in CD 28 - need more cockpit room!
Moderator: Jim Walsh
-
- Posts: 15
- Joined: Mar 13th, '09, 21:48
- Location: 1980 28 ft CD sloop - San Francisco CA
Hull #260
Tiller VS. Wheel in CD 28 - need more cockpit room!
I have owned my CD 28 (Escape) for about 1.5 years and have done a lot of repairs & updating during that time (will post pics) and have come to the conclusion I would like to switch from tiller to wheel - for the sole reason I do not have enough room in the cockpit for people to sit - without them being in the way of the tiller - is there a "to-do" instructions for the change?
I also welcome any sage advice on other thoughts & options regarding this issue (mini-tiller?). With all the changes and work - I probably should have bought a CD30!
On an unrelated note - is the bilge area under the engine open, meaning water cannot be trapped away from the bilge pump? The reason I ask this question, with all the rain we have had in the SF bay area - my bilge filled up and the lower unit went out - thankfully I had installed a second pump between the first pump and the cabin floor which kept the cabin from flooding. What was strange was the fact that the hand pump in the cockpit did not affect this bilge water and lead me to wonder if there are "compartments" in bilge - or is my hand-pump hose plugged or in the wrong location - it has worked in the past w/o issue - appreciate your thoughts - waitin for spring - Warren
I also welcome any sage advice on other thoughts & options regarding this issue (mini-tiller?). With all the changes and work - I probably should have bought a CD30!
On an unrelated note - is the bilge area under the engine open, meaning water cannot be trapped away from the bilge pump? The reason I ask this question, with all the rain we have had in the SF bay area - my bilge filled up and the lower unit went out - thankfully I had installed a second pump between the first pump and the cabin floor which kept the cabin from flooding. What was strange was the fact that the hand pump in the cockpit did not affect this bilge water and lead me to wonder if there are "compartments" in bilge - or is my hand-pump hose plugged or in the wrong location - it has worked in the past w/o issue - appreciate your thoughts - waitin for spring - Warren
-
- Posts: 86
- Joined: Aug 7th, '09, 14:21
- Location: 1978 Cape Dory 28 #174, Sanuye, Melbourne, Florida
To me I think that the wheel might be a little better while sailing when you have to turn, but alot worse at anchor (or dock). You can't tie it up out of the way like you can a tiller. Also with the wheel you don't really know which way the rudder is facing like you do with a tiller.
I guess one good thing would be that if you have inexperienced people aboard, I would think that they would more easily be able to steer the boat with a wheel than a tiller.
I suppose if you could somehow mount the wheel on the back wall of the cockpit (behind where the tiller connects) then it might be pretty good and out of the way...but you still don't know the rudder direction.
As far as the bilge pump issue, make sure your manual bilge pump hose is down in the bottom, and not clogged up with junk, and doesn't have a hole in it somewhere where the pump can suck air rather than the water in the bilge. As far as being compartmentalized, mine doesn't have seperate compartments, and I think that's the original setup.
-Dave
I guess one good thing would be that if you have inexperienced people aboard, I would think that they would more easily be able to steer the boat with a wheel than a tiller.
I suppose if you could somehow mount the wheel on the back wall of the cockpit (behind where the tiller connects) then it might be pretty good and out of the way...but you still don't know the rudder direction.
As far as the bilge pump issue, make sure your manual bilge pump hose is down in the bottom, and not clogged up with junk, and doesn't have a hole in it somewhere where the pump can suck air rather than the water in the bilge. As far as being compartmentalized, mine doesn't have seperate compartments, and I think that's the original setup.
-Dave
tiller or wheel
Zephyr had wheel steering when I bought her in '99. After about five years I changed back to tiller, which is the original set-up. Looking back I can see positives and negatives for both options. If I had it to do over, I would go with tiller again.
The wheel option does give more cockpit room while underway. The compass is on centerline and directly in front of the helm. Instrument readouts can be clustered there for easy viewing. The wheel gives a greater mechanical advantage meaning less muscle effort to helm. With a SS tubing binnacle guard mounted, you have a nice hand-hold in the center of the cockpit. A folding teak table can be attached which is a very nice feature in port or at anchor. Some folks like the look of a wheel more than tiller.
Some disadvantages include reduced cockpit space when not underway. There is no designed seating for a wheel, so this is an issue. (If you go to a wheel, send me a PM---I still have a seat I made.) Going to and from the helm position is awkward because the layout isn't designed for this. If you have a bimini, it's harder to see the sails. The helmsperson is at the back of the cockpit and can't easily reach jib sheets (or main sheet with a cabintop traveler). And there are more moving parts to fail.
But the biggest disadvantage for me was that all that additional weight aft---the wheel, the binnacle, instruments, autopilot, underdeck pulleys mounts, cables and quadrant, the seat and the helmsperson---put the boat out of trim. She squatted at the stern and lifted at the bow and this affected sailing performance.
The advantages and disadvantages of the tiller are pretty much the flip side of the wheel. But she does sail better w/o the weight aft. And with a tiller extension it's much easier to see the sails and work the lines, especially short-handed or single-handed.
I'm a bit challenged with cyberspace skills, but I'll try to hook you up with a photobucket album of the wheel steering set-up. (It's already been sold, btw.) Here 'tis:
http://s199.photobucket.com/albums/aa12 ... 0steering/
Hope this helps. Bob
The wheel option does give more cockpit room while underway. The compass is on centerline and directly in front of the helm. Instrument readouts can be clustered there for easy viewing. The wheel gives a greater mechanical advantage meaning less muscle effort to helm. With a SS tubing binnacle guard mounted, you have a nice hand-hold in the center of the cockpit. A folding teak table can be attached which is a very nice feature in port or at anchor. Some folks like the look of a wheel more than tiller.
Some disadvantages include reduced cockpit space when not underway. There is no designed seating for a wheel, so this is an issue. (If you go to a wheel, send me a PM---I still have a seat I made.) Going to and from the helm position is awkward because the layout isn't designed for this. If you have a bimini, it's harder to see the sails. The helmsperson is at the back of the cockpit and can't easily reach jib sheets (or main sheet with a cabintop traveler). And there are more moving parts to fail.
But the biggest disadvantage for me was that all that additional weight aft---the wheel, the binnacle, instruments, autopilot, underdeck pulleys mounts, cables and quadrant, the seat and the helmsperson---put the boat out of trim. She squatted at the stern and lifted at the bow and this affected sailing performance.
The advantages and disadvantages of the tiller are pretty much the flip side of the wheel. But she does sail better w/o the weight aft. And with a tiller extension it's much easier to see the sails and work the lines, especially short-handed or single-handed.
I'm a bit challenged with cyberspace skills, but I'll try to hook you up with a photobucket album of the wheel steering set-up. (It's already been sold, btw.) Here 'tis:
http://s199.photobucket.com/albums/aa12 ... 0steering/
Hope this helps. Bob
It's a project
I did this when I first got my boat at the insistance of a partner, it was a mistake. The original Edson worm drive,(I have a 30) is a fine steering system that has few issues and afforded more room on the cockpit than the new pedestal/wheel.
A new unit from Edson will cost 2k plus.
The rudder will have to be dropped and the stock, rudder tube adjusted.
A lot of work here, on mine the shaft and tube were shortened. The tube reinforced and glassed in.
A packing bearing installed on the tube.
I found the cockpit floor needed rebuilding.
New engine controls installed in the pedestal.
My system works great, but in hindsight, I regret changing it.
________
FUTURA
A new unit from Edson will cost 2k plus.
The rudder will have to be dropped and the stock, rudder tube adjusted.
A lot of work here, on mine the shaft and tube were shortened. The tube reinforced and glassed in.
A packing bearing installed on the tube.
I found the cockpit floor needed rebuilding.
New engine controls installed in the pedestal.
My system works great, but in hindsight, I regret changing it.
________
FUTURA
Last edited by Ron M. on Feb 11th, '11, 06:16, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 1300
- Joined: Nov 21st, '05, 08:20
- Location: CD28 Cruiser "Loon" Poorhouse Cove, ME
Rudder Position
Everyone has made some excellent points. I need to disagree with one statement about the rudder position. If you mark the top of the wheel with a turks head or even electrical tape, and you know that one complete revolution puts the helm hard over, then it's pretty simple to figure out the rudder position by the position of the top of the helm. It's not hard. You get a feel for it pretty quickly.
Also, the wheel actually comes off really easily. If you're planning on entertaining at anchor, you can simply remove the wheel temporarily.
Also, the wheel actually comes off really easily. If you're planning on entertaining at anchor, you can simply remove the wheel temporarily.
CDSOA Commodore - Member No. 725
"The more I expand the island of my knowledge, the more I expand the shoreline of my wonder"
Sir Isaac Newton
"The more I expand the island of my knowledge, the more I expand the shoreline of my wonder"
Sir Isaac Newton
-
- Posts: 380
- Joined: Mar 14th, '05, 09:14
Re: Tiller VS. Wheel in CD 28 - need more cockpit room!
With a 28 footer (I have owned one for close to 3 decades), you might consider the following questions before changing to a wheel:warrenescape wrote:I have ... come to the conclusion I would like to switch from tiller to wheel ... I do not have enough room in the cockpit for people to sit ...
Which is cheaper? Easy enough.
Which is simpler? Also fairly clear.
Which is inherently more reliable? See preceding answer.
Which adds realizable value at resale time? Buyer-dependent.
Which is easiest, cheapest, and simplest for autopilots or vane steering? Obvious.
Now for a few personal questions:
Do you really take several friends each time you leave the dock? Cut back on your invitations and social life until you own a CD 45.
Can you get more accommodating friends? There are lonely folks everywhere who would love company.
Will a cat do instead? I likes dogs, my wife likes cats.
On a serious note my point is that the boat should first and foremost accommodate you and your family. Let me elaborate. In my travels I have encountered many folks who have a bigger boat than they really wanted so "the kids can visit us in the Bahamas," or "our daughter's friend likes to stay overnight," or [fill in the blanks]. Without exception these folks confessed over a glass of cheap scotch that they made a mistake. This often happens after a night of dragging anchor in a crowded anchorage and trying to reset that 65 pound device up front that seemed to weigh much more when covered with slimy mud and attached to an equally slimy chain.
Modifying an otherwise sensible design falls into this category when the changes under consideration are primarily for guests or other necessary inconveniences. If your guests are sailors, they can take the pain. If not, get substitutes. Still, "ya pays yure money and ya takes yure chances."
Last edited by The Patriot on Mar 11th, '10, 14:27, edited 1 time in total.
Worm Gear / Rack and Pinion
Has anyone ever thought (or actually done it) about putting a worm gear or rack and pinion style wheel steering set up on a 28?
Similar to what I have seen on the 30's.
It seems that set up might work on a 28.
Similar to what I have seen on the 30's.
It seems that set up might work on a 28.
-
- Posts: 3535
- Joined: Feb 5th, '05, 20:42
- Location: '66 Typhoon "Grace", Hull # 42, Schooner "Ontario", CD 85D Hull #1
Re: Tiller VS. Wheel in CD 28 - need more cockpit room!
I believe that the area under the engine is open. Water should flow downward to the bilge.warrenescape wrote: On an unrelated note - is the bilge area under the engine open, meaning water cannot be trapped away from the bilge pump? The reason I ask this question, with all the rain we have had in the SF bay area - my bilge filled up and the lower unit went out - thankfully I had installed a second pump between the first pump and the cabin floor which kept the cabin from flooding.
- appreciate your thoughts - waitin for spring - Warren
What some people do is add food coloring to several gallons of water and pour the colored water into the area under the engine. The colored water should appear in the bilge.
As far as determining 0° rudder angle position, with a tiller this is obvious. With a wheel, as Carl mentioned, there should be some designation of 0° angle. Some people designate this with a marked "king spoke" of the wheel usually at 12:00 o'clock. A turks head knot or even tape on the rim would show this.
O J
Last edited by Oswego John on Feb 26th, '10, 14:19, edited 1 time in total.
"If I rest, I rust"
Voting Member #490
Voting Member #490
-
- Posts: 218
- Joined: Aug 28th, '06, 18:38
- Location: Cape Dory 28 "VASA" #144 Annapolis, MD
Wheel vs tiller
Wow! Lots of discussion following the initial question: Wheel vs tiller. I own a 28 and believe the designer Carl Alberg knew what he was doing when he put a tiller in the 28 and a wheel in the 30. The latter is longer and thus more room in the cockpit. Why change to a tiller in a 28? I sail both single-handed and with several people and have yet to find the cockpit so crowded that I can't steer the boat. As one 25 owner mentioned one can always lift the tiller up a bit when turning to prevent it from hitting someone in the head.
And the expense of converting from the existing tiller to a wheel is in my opinion definitely not worth it!
And the expense of converting from the existing tiller to a wheel is in my opinion definitely not worth it!
Within the the unlocked homes of the Swedish villages on the shores of the Baltic around the rocks sings the sea.
When I was initially shopping for a CD28, the first thing to remove a boat from my list was a wheel. I sailed KAYLA for 8 years, spring, summer, fall and winter. I have taken out as many was 9 people - yes, the cockpit was crowded, but I had no problem standing to helm for the entire sail. OK, it was a light air day, but that was fine since most of the folks had never sailed before! Each and everyone said they enjoyed it very much; a few even came back the next day for more! ![Wink ;-)](./images/smilies/icon_wink.gif)
A small block of teak or starboard can be inserted under the tiller to keep it raised above "knee level" and work just fine. I do miss not having a tiller on Tranquil, but since she has a worm drive helm, I have adapted fairly well. If the helm had been cable driven, I doubt we would have bought her!
-mike & Toni
![Wink ;-)](./images/smilies/icon_wink.gif)
A small block of teak or starboard can be inserted under the tiller to keep it raised above "knee level" and work just fine. I do miss not having a tiller on Tranquil, but since she has a worm drive helm, I have adapted fairly well. If the helm had been cable driven, I doubt we would have bought her!
-mike & Toni
-michael & Toni CDSOA #789
s/v KAYLA CD28 #318
2012 FLSTC Heritage Classic
Niceville FL
+30° 30' 24.60", -86° 26' 32.10"
"Just because it worked, doesn't mean it works." -me
No shirt + No shorts = No problem!
s/v KAYLA CD28 #318
2012 FLSTC Heritage Classic
Niceville FL
+30° 30' 24.60", -86° 26' 32.10"
"Just because it worked, doesn't mean it works." -me
No shirt + No shorts = No problem!
-
- Posts: 86
- Joined: Aug 7th, '09, 14:21
- Location: 1978 Cape Dory 28 #174, Sanuye, Melbourne, Florida
Re: Rudder Position
You're trying to back out of a slip and you're fending the boat off the dock as your crew mans the helm. The boat isn't going exactly where you want and you look back to see what they're doing. The tape on the wheel is at the 3:00 position. Is it turned 1/4 to starboard, or 3/4 to port?Carl Thunberg wrote: I need to disagree with one statement about the rudder position. If you mark the top of the wheel with a turks head or even electrical tape, and you know that one complete revolution puts the helm hard over, then it's pretty simple to figure out the rudder position by the position of the top of the helm. It's not hard. You get a feel for it pretty quickly.
I'm just trying to say that you can, at a glance, tell which way the rudder is facing with a tiller.
Last edited by DaveCD28 on Mar 8th, '10, 11:54, edited 1 time in total.
- David van den Burgh
- Posts: 597
- Joined: Feb 5th, '05, 18:54
- Location: Ariel CD36, 1979 - Lake Michigan
- Contact:
Re: Rudder Position
That's easy: It doesn't matter. Rudder direction doesn't have an impact on a CD in reverse. Nice trick question. Next.gmppz28 wrote:You're trying to back out of a slip and you're fending the boat off the dock as your crew mans the helm. The boat isn't going exactly where you want and you look back to see what they're doing. The tape on the wheel is at the 3:00 position. Is it turned 1/4 to starboard, or 3/4 to port?
(Now watch as the discussion shifts from tiller vs wheel to "How I manage to back my Cape Dory like Mario Andretti")
Last edited by David van den Burgh on Mar 8th, '10, 12:03, edited 1 time in total.
- Sea Hunt
- Posts: 1310
- Joined: Jan 29th, '06, 23:14
- Location: Former caretaker of 1977 Cape Dory Typhoon Weekender (Hull #1400) "S/V Tadpole"
Hello David:
For the admitted "dummy" in this group ("porch light's on but nobody's home"; "elevator doesn't go to the top floor"; "dumber than dirt"; "doesn't have two brain cells to rub together" etc., etc., etc. - I have heard them all and more many, many times
), can you (or anyone) explain in simple words, with simple diagrams if possible, why a rudder has "no impact on a CD in reverse"
I understand the rudder impact may be somewhat reduced from that of a rudder on a fin keel sailboat because we "enjoy" a full keel, but why would the rudder have NO IMPACT. When departing my mooring or departing our club dock, I have on occasion had to be in (or go into) reverse to maneuver. It seemed a little sluggish but with the tiller over on port or starboard (depending on intended direction, etc.) it seemed to "help" my little Tadpole.
What am I missing
Again, please remember - simple, short words. Otherwise I will not understand the explanation.
P.S. I hope these post passes the grammar and spelling police editors.
I'll may dun the bestus I cuda witth the wittle brainys God given to mi. ![Wink :wink:](./images/smilies/icon_wink.gif)
For the admitted "dummy" in this group ("porch light's on but nobody's home"; "elevator doesn't go to the top floor"; "dumber than dirt"; "doesn't have two brain cells to rub together" etc., etc., etc. - I have heard them all and more many, many times
![Crying or Very sad :cry:](./images/smilies/icon_cry.gif)
![Crying or Very sad :cry:](./images/smilies/icon_cry.gif)
![Crying or Very sad :cry:](./images/smilies/icon_cry.gif)
![Question :?:](./images/smilies/icon_question.gif)
I understand the rudder impact may be somewhat reduced from that of a rudder on a fin keel sailboat because we "enjoy" a full keel, but why would the rudder have NO IMPACT. When departing my mooring or departing our club dock, I have on occasion had to be in (or go into) reverse to maneuver. It seemed a little sluggish but with the tiller over on port or starboard (depending on intended direction, etc.) it seemed to "help" my little Tadpole.
What am I missing
![Question :?:](./images/smilies/icon_question.gif)
P.S. I hope these post passes the grammar and spelling police editors.
![Very Happy :D](./images/smilies/icon_biggrin.gif)
![Very Happy :D](./images/smilies/icon_biggrin.gif)
![Wink :wink:](./images/smilies/icon_wink.gif)
Fair winds,
Robert
Sea Hunt a/k/a "The Tadpole Sailor"
CDSOA #1097
Robert
Sea Hunt a/k/a "The Tadpole Sailor"
CDSOA #1097